Torah from Rabbanim w Yirat Shamaym

Feed it and it hungers

אִם יִרְצֶה הַשֵּׁם

י׳ כִּסְלֵו תשפ״ז

The sugya continues on Sanhedrin 107a. Tape: Perek Chelek 34. Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l. Before this: The way down is slippery (Perek Chelek 32).

Neither post nor transcript has been reviewed by Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l nor the Toras Avigdor organization.

Teacher, then comrade, then disciple

Va-ata enosh ke-erki alufi u-meyuda'i: you are a man like my worth, my leader, the one known to me.

Rabbi Yochanan: at the beginning David called Achitofel his rabi. Afterward they walked together in the sweet secrets of the Torah, in the Beis Elokim, and he was his chaver. At the end, ish shelomi asher batachti bo ha-ochel lachmi higdil alai akev: the man of my peace whom I trusted, who ate of my bread, because I taught him the Torah, raised his heel against me. David forged ahead in greatness. Achitofel did not. He had the Torah on his lips, not in his heart. A man who goes in the darkei Hashem has success in everything, including learning. That is one reason Achitofel became incensed and sought to overthrow him.

Torah that stays on the lips does not keep pace.

Do not volunteer

Al yavi adam atzmo li-yedei nisayon: a man should never bring himself to a test.

Do not try to show that you are a hero. Run from any danger of a chet. Overcoming a great temptation brings more reward. We still do not seek that reward when falling is the danger. Plenty of tests come upon us unwillingly. David asked why later generations mention the Avos in tefillah and will not say his name. They were tested. He was not. Avraham withstood ten. Bochani: strike the metal and see if it breaks. Naseini: give me the ordeals. As it says, bechanani Hashem ve-naseini. HaKadosh Baruch Hu answered: I will test you, and I will tell you the subject beforehand. In a matter of ervah. Be prepared. To the others it came as a surprise. David was not the equal of Avraham, so the warning was an advantage. Only the greatest were chosen at the beginning, Shaul and then David over him because he was more perfect. This perfect man sought the test and stumbled.

The most perfect man volunteered, and he fell.

A get, and a rebel

Penuyah: unmarried. Mored be-malchus: a rebel against the king.

Everybody who went out to war gave his wife a get, so she would not be left an agunah if he were missing. It was proper that she wait, and remarry after the war. Uriah was of the party of Yoav. David was not able to execute Yoav as he deserved. He left that to Shlomo. Uriah he would put in the front, so the enemy would slay him. Batsheva was not officially married. Uriah was not supposed to come back. There is no technical aveira. The moral fault remains. She was expected to wait for her husband.

She was a penuyah. She was still expected to wait.

He turned night into day

Hevel katan yesh be-adam masbi'o ra'ev, mar'ivo save'a: feed the small organ and it hungers; starve it and it is full.

Va-yehi le-et erev va-yakam David me-al mishkavo. He rose from his marriage bed and turned the time of night into the time of day. He had eighteen wives, and it is a man's duty not to neglect each one. These things are usually by day. By night there is nothing to see. A talmid chacham may change the time when it is necessary, and especially if it is dark and there are no windows. He hoped that by day he would have no temptation. The halacha was concealed from him. The more a person is indulgent to himself, the more he is open to the yetzer hara. When he gave in by day, he became hungrier.

He fed it, and it hungered.

The bird and the booth

Va-yar isha rochetzet me-al ha-gag: he saw a woman bathing, from on top of the roof. Toisi chalos: underneath a booth.

Keep away from roofs. David did not yet have Masechet Pesachim. He walked on the roof of the king's house. In the neighboring courtyard was a mikveh. Batsheva was washing her head in hot water, under a light tent of straw, before the tevilah. She would not have done that exposed to public view. The yetzer hara made itself resemble a bird. David shot to keep his skill as a man of war. Jews do not hunt. The arrow knocked the booth over. She was revealed. She went through the tevilah and was pure from her niddah. He sent and inquired. They told him: Batsheva bas Eliam, the wife of Uriah the Hittite. He heard the get, and he heard the name of the man he had already sentenced. He sent messengers and took her. She was tehorah and a penuyah. Technically he committed no sin at all. Kol ha-omer David chata eino ela to'eh: anyone who says David sinned is only in error. In the eyes of Hashem it was still wrong. Underneath, he felt the wager: lest people say the servant overcame his master. That weakened him. He could have overcome the moral issue. He did not make the effort, because it was not a real aveira.

No technical aveira. The moral fault remained, and the wager weakened him.

A green fig

Tzela: a rib and a support, or a dislocation and a ruin. Zacha ezer, lo zacha negdo.

Re'uyah hayta Batsheva le-David mi-sheshes yemei bereishis: she was fit for him from the six days of creation. Had he waited, she would have come without this problem. He took her while she was still a green fig, before the time. Tzela holds both the help she was meant to be and the ruin that followed. The distress stayed with him always.

He took her before the time.

The lame who gathered

Ha-ba al eshet ish mito be-chenek: the man who comes on a married woman is put to death by strangulation. Ha-malbin pnei chaveiro be-rabbim ein lo chelek: one who shames his fellow in public has no share.

They had opposed him from the start, because of the Moabite ancestry and because of his gifts in war, in Torah, and in music. When this happened they pounced and never remained silent. When he was limping, the nechim gathered, people with broken or lame feet of their own, and they tore at the limp. Even when the yeshiva learned the four deaths, they brought it around to him. He answered the din: strangulation, and he still has a chelek if he does teshuvah. Public shame has no chelek, because that teshuvah needs mechila from the other person. David was an all-powerful king and could have silenced them. He did not. He felt he deserved it. Even when he was ill he kept his duty to his eighteen wives. He was vigorous. He still would not compete with Hashem over something that was not a real aveira.

He could have silenced them. He did not.

The real reason

Yefas to'ar: the Gentile woman taken in battle, permitted by the Torah, and set next to the parsha of ben sorer u-moreh.

When Avshalom rose with Achitofel, David wanted to bow to an idol, or to leave the land, only so that people would say that was why his son rose, and there would be no chilul Hashem upon a devoted servant. Chushai stopped him. That show would be another chilul. Better they should know the real reason. You took a yefas to'ar. The Torah permits it. The bad son is explained by the mother, not by any great sin of David.

The permitted act still sits next to the rebellious son.

A stain remains

Shegiyot mi yavin. Mi-mistarim nakeini. Gam mi-zedim chasoch avdecha. Al yimshalu bi. Ehei tahor.

He bargained like a Kusi merchant, a little at a time: the errors, the hidden sins, the open ones, that the later Rabbanan not condemn him, and that the sin not be written in the Tanakh. The nevi'im were loyal to the house of David, and the house had the power to suppress the story. They wrote it in the worst way, with none of the extenuating facts. David and his children could have stopped it. They did not. He asked that the nevi'im themselves erase it. Impossible. The yud taken from Sarai cried out until it was given to Yehoshua. An entire parashah cannot be erased. Forgiveness means he will not be punished. A stain remains on the neshama, like a wine stain that is mostly gone and still visible if you look. Shlomo will say that one who takes fire into his lap is not cleansed. To remove the last vestige, David accepted suffering of his own. For six months he was a metzora. The Shechinah left him. The Sanhedrin left him. Techate'eni be-ezov: the hyssop of the leper. Hashiva li seson yishecha: return the joy of Your company. Yashuvu li yere'echa. The six months are not counted among the years in Chevron. He was in isolation outside the camp. He asked for a public sign that he was forgiven. In his lifetime it would not be given. He would bear the critics for the rest of his days.

The punishment can be lifted. The stain is still there if you look.

The measure was exact

The entrance and the Aron were measured to the same size, and it would not go through.

The greatest craftsmen had measured both with precision. When the Mikdash was finished, the Aron would not enter. It was a Yad Hashem oversight, so that the public demonstration could occur. Shlomo said twenty-four tefillos. None were answered.

The tape stops. What is left of the public sign in David's lifetime, and how far does the small organ run once he had already been told the subject of the test?


Support the dissemination of Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l's shiurim at Kol Avigdor. To dedicate a daf: Sponsor a daf.