אִם יִרְצֶה הַשֵּׁם
ח׳ כִּסְלֵו תשפ״ז
The sugya continues on Sanhedrin 105b, into 106a. Tape: Perek Chelek 32. Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l. Before this: A kingdom without a crown.
Neither post nor transcript has been reviewed by Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l nor the Toras Avigdor organization.
The reed still stands
Kaneh: a reed that grows in a wet place. Erez: a cedar.
The curse of the good friend is better than the kisses of the enemy. Achiyo ha-Shiloni compared Yisrael to the reed. It cannot stand against the wind, so it bends. When the wind passes it returns, and it is not uprooted. From that reed they take the pen for Torah, Nevi'im, and Kesuvim. Bilam compared them to the cedar. It holds against an ordinary wind. A hurricane tears it out, and it is finished. The friend means our benefit: be rebuked, and change. The enemy means no benefit at all. We bend before the storms and we still endure. We remain the people of the book, because we go on writing.
Bend with the wind, and the pen is still in your hand.
You were in that counsel
Vayar et ha-keni: and he saw the Kenite.
Bilam raises his mashal. Your seat is firm. You have placed your nest upon a rock. He speaks from a distance to the family of Yisro: were you not with us in that counsel against Am Yisrael? Paroh summoned the wise men of the nations around him. Bilam of Aram and Yisro of Midian sat together. Now you sit secure with a people that is powerful forever. Anyone who joins Am Yisrael becomes a ger and shares that eternity. Yisro was there at the beginning. When he heard the plan he excused himself for a moment, went outside, and disappeared. He wanted no part in the scheme. For that he was worthy to come to the safe place with Am Yisrael, and his descendants sat in the Lishkas ha-Gazis.
Three were in that counsel. Bilam, who advised, was killed. He had been present when the plan was made to throw the children into the river, so he was older than Moshe, and he died earlier, about the same age. Iyov, who remained silent, was judged with yissurim. Yisro, who fled, put his line in the marble chamber of the Sanhedrin.
Once the wrong path is chosen, the way down is slippery.
Who will live
Oy mi yichye mi-sumo Kel.
One reading, the one the censor erased: alas for the one who makes himself great in the name of God. The other: who will have the next world if he lived only for the pleasures of this world, when HaKadosh Baruch Hu puts him to judgment. Abaye: oy to the nation that is found there when HaKadosh Baruch Hu makes a redemption for His children. The nations will try to prevent the geulah, and they will be crushed. A man who throws down his garment to nap between a lion and a lioness, at the moment they wish to join, is mangled by both. When HaKadosh Baruch Hu is reunited with His people, those who stand in the way are mangled.
Do not lie down in the path of that reunion.
Ashur in its turn
Ve-tzim mi-yad Kitim: warships from the islands of Kitim will afflict Ashur.
Ashur is the symbol of golus, because the first exile, the Ten Tribes, was in its hand. How long will Ashur keep you captive? A great navy comes, and the nations that harm Yisrael are punished each in its turn. Who is killed, and who is only subjected, stays mysterious even in the Chumash.
The hand that holds Am Yisrael captive does not keep its hold.
He hung the curse on them
I will counsel you what this people will do to your people.
He was about to counsel what Moav would do to Yisrael, the scheme that caused twenty-four thousand of Shevet Shimon to perish. A man who is about to curse himself hangs the curse on others. The Torah does not want those words in Bilam's mouth, so the order is turned. The blow that lands on Moav is the blow Moav wanted for Yisrael.
He hung his own curse on them.
Linen, wine, and Peor
Elokeihem shel elu soneh zimah: their God hates immorality.
There is no Shechinah where there are mixed dances, or a room built so that one must look at women, or where women come indecently dressed. Wool they had from their own sheep. Linen, in the desert, was the thing they wanted. So: booths of curtains, and in them the women and the daughters. Kozbi bat Tzur, a princess, was put to the work. An old woman sits outside with the cloth. A young woman waits inside. The men of Shevet Shimon will not buy from a girl, and they think an old woman is safe. After the meal, full and with nothing to do, he hears the fair price, then the lower price from inside. After two visits and a third she says he is already like a man of the household: sit and choose. The Amoni wine is heavy, and the prohibition on the wine of the nations is not yet in force. He drinks, he is inflamed, he proposes. She brings out Peor. Worship this. Am I not a Jew? What do you care? They desire nothing but that you uncover yourself. He thinks it is scorn. Once the act is done, the intent follows, and she will not let go until he denies the teaching of Moshe his teacher. In the camp the women were covered and stayed inside. Here the young ones, boys of thirteen, fourteen, and fifteen, walked in for merchandise and were overwhelmed. The women said: take us with you, and we will become Jewesses. That was the door. From shegag to mezid, and not yet a denial that the Torah is from Heaven, though the slip can lead there.
The yetzer climbs in order: a full stomach, a luxury, a woman, then an idol.
The soft place
Why Shevet Shimon more than the others?
Yaakov cursed Shimon and Levi together. Levi took the anger that had brought the curse and turned it into zeal. When Moshe said "Who is for Hashem, to me," the whole tribe of Levi gathered. They put to death the three thousand at the egel. Pinchas the kanai stopped the plague. Later the kohanim of the Chashmonaim rose to defend the Torah. From the fault they made their chief virtue. Shimon never redeemed itself. In ve-Zos ha-Beracha every tribe receives a blessing except Shimon. Every tribe received a portion. Even Levi received the cities of refuge. Shimon received nothing, and remained visitors in the land of others. It was the weakest of the tribes. The yetzer is a fly that circles an apple and looks for the soft place where it can settle and suck. A man does not sin unless a spirit of shtus enters him, and that spirit enters only where there is a vacuum. Torah fills the head and leaves no room. The place is called Shittim because the whole episode came from emptiness.
The fly sits only where the apple is soft.
Hands that let go
Refidim: the name of the place, or rofu yedeihem, their hands became weak.
Amalek cut off those who lagged behind. Or they made themselves weak from the words of Torah, like men who go out when the Torah is read. The merit of the fathers did not protect children whose hands were weak in Torah. Those who stayed close to the teachers, and walked with the body of the people, were not taken.
Zechus avos does not cover hands that let go of Torah.
And he dwelt
Va-yeshev: and he dwelt. Wherever the Torah says it, the next thing is distress.
It means he tried to take it easy. In this world we are here to accomplish. We relax in the next. Yaakov spent fourteen years in the yeshiva of Shem and Ever and never once lay down, then the years for Lavan and the meeting with Esav. He asked for a little peace, and the trouble of Yosef leaped upon him. HaKadosh Baruch Hu said: the righteous are busy in this world. You will relax in the next. The same word is waiting elsewhere. Yisrael dwelt in Shittim and went after the daughters of Moav. In Egypt they thought they were safe, Yosef second to the king, and the days of Yisrael drew near to die. Under Shlomo each man sat under his vine and his fig tree, and Hashem raised Hadad and Shishak, after Egypt had lain low for five hundred years from the Exodus. Tzaddikim have no rest in this world or in the next. There they progress without the labor.
The rest he asked for was the trouble arriving.
The camel that sought horns
Ve-et Bilam ben Beor hargu ba-cherev: and Bilam son of Beor they slew with the sword.
In the war against Midian he was found and slain. He had said he was going home. He went to collect his wages for the twenty-four thousand he had caused to fall, from Midian and from Moav. A camel is a useful beast when it accepts its lot and carries loads. If it wants horns, so that it can be grand and fearful like a bull, even the ears it already has are cut off. Bilam could have remained in Aram and taught emunah to the nations. He tried to change from a navi into an oppressor, and to put on horns against Am Yisrael, and he lost everything. At first he was a navi. At the end he was a kosem. The mashal is a woman who had sat among princes and rulers, and ended as a harlot of laborers. They fulfilled on him the four deaths, skilah, sreifah, hereg, and chenek, for the great sins he committed and the great sins he caused.
He reached for horns and lost the ears he had.
It is not written
A min once said to R Chanina: "Did you hear how old Bilam was?"
He answered: "It is not written."
The tape stops. What is the force of the question, and of that answer?
Support the dissemination of Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l's shiurim at Kol Avigdor. To dedicate a daf: Sponsor a daf.