אִם יִרְצֶה הַשֵּׁם
ח׳ כִּסְלֵו תשפ״ז
The sugya continues on Sanhedrin 105a. Tape: Perek Chelek 31. Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l. Yesterday: Without the people.
Neither post nor transcript has been reviewed by Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l nor the Toras Avigdor organization.
A kingdom without a crown
Chutzpah malchuta belo taga: a kingdom without a crown.
David was king. The sons of Tzeruyah were harder. They had azus panim. Hashem yields in two ways. He leads a man on the path the man insists on: Bilam kept asking, was told to go, and met his death. He also weighs pain, even a wicked man's. Esav's tears brought galus. The shame of Kamsa bar Kamsa became the spark. Ayin hara counts. Do not display what hurts another.
Boldness obtains a result. It does not mean it pays.
The limp and the closed eye
Vayelech shefi: he went limping. Shetum ha'ayin: one eye closed.
Bilam was not born that way. Heaven sent the limp and the closed eye when he set out to curse. An old man suddenly lame should have stopped. Shimshon was lame on both feet (shefifon). He never fought in the open. He harassed the Pelishtim like a snake at the heel, and he left his people to live among them. The remez stood. He did not.
A defect that appears on a bad path is a message to stop.
Not his own knowledge
Yode'a da'as elyon: he knows the knowledge of the Most High.
The Torah says it, so it is true. The nevuah was a gift, so the nations could not say they had no prophet. Da'as behemah he lacked. The donkey spoke and won.
The words were Hashem's. The man was not that great.
No moment left
Mah ekov lo kaboh Kel: how can I curse whom Hashem does not curse.
He knew the daily rega of anger, in the first three hours, when the rooster's comb is fully pale. He meant to curse then. Hashem suspended that anger the whole time. Kings bow to the sun, and Hashem allows a brief za'am at that mistake. A min tried to catch the moment against R Yehoshua b Levi and slept through it.
The anger was withheld. Cursing is not derech eretz, even against a min.
The same saddle
Ahavah mevatel shuras gedulah: love cancels the rank.
Avraham rose early and saddled his own donkey for love of Hashem. Hatred does the same. Bilam's hatred of Yisrael made him forget his dignity and saddle himself.
Love and hatred both make a great man forget his rank.
Forty-two offerings
Mi-tokh she-lo lishmah ba lishmah: from not-for-its-own-sake comes for-its-own-sake.
Balak brought forty-two korbanos only to gain a curse. From that line came Rus, through Eglon. Rav Yisrael Salanter, as Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l brings him: shelo lishmah becomes lishmah when the act already has every geder of lishmah, done properly, al pi ha-halachah, with the kovod the act requires. Say that Balak offered with real respect. Naomi drew out what was already in Rus. The seed helped. It did not decide the flower.
The form can already be lishmah. The intent still has to catch up.
One curse stayed a blessing
Va-yahafoch Hashem Elokecha lecha et ha-klalah li-vrachah: the curse, singular, turned into a blessing.
He tried to spoil each bracha with one bad word. A malach finished the sentence, or a chakah stopped his mouth. Read backward, he wanted no gathering for Torah, no lasting malchus, no orchards, no son after father, no rule, and no bold kingdom that puts fear on the nations. Most of that later came true. The batei kenesiyos and batei midrashos did not.
One intended klalah remains a bracha.
Reed, not cedar
Kaneh: a reed in water, bending and still standing. Erez: a cedar the south wind uproots.
Achia ha-Shiloni cursed them to be the reed. Bilam blessed them to be the cedar. The curse was better. The reed also gives the pen for the books of the prophets.
Achia's curse outlasts Bilam's blessing.
You Kenite
Vayar et ha-keni: and he saw the Kenite.
He lifts his mashal and says to Yisro: "You Kenite, were you not with us in the counsel?"
The tape stops. What is the full force of that rebuke?
Support the dissemination of Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l's shiurim at Kol Avigdor. To dedicate a daf: Sponsor a daf.