Torah from Rabbanim w Yirat Shamaym

Without the people

אִם יִרְצֶה הַשֵּׁם

ו׳ כִּסְלֵו תשפ״ז

The sugya continues on Sanhedrin 104b. Tape: Perek Chelek 30. Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l. On the previous tape: Like a widow.

Neither post nor transcript has been reviewed by Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l nor the Toras Avigdor organization.

Gilad is Mine

Li Gilad: Gilad is Mine. And Menashe, and Efrayim the strength of My head, Yehudah My lawgiver, Moav the pot of My washing, upon Edom I cast My shoe.

Those who expound the hints say all of them come to olam ha-ba. The Shechinah claims each one by a virtue that remains: Achav, who fell fighting for the people; Menashe the king; Yeravam, once in great favor; Achitofel, the great chacham; Gehazi, who served his master; Doeg, at least a footstool. Yesterday's tape stopped while Doeg was still being explained. This tape finishes the list. Why bathing, of all things? Service of a teacher is greater than study. Elisha is praised for pouring water on the hands of Eliyahu. Yehoshua is praised as the attendant of Moshe.

Alai Peleshet hisro'a'i: upon me Philistia will show friendship.

The angels object that David's enemies are restored. The answer is that for Hashem's sake they will be reconciled. It may be that this does not differ with the Mishnah: the punishment stands for a time, and then it ends. In the plain sense it looks like a disagreement.

HaKadosh Baruch Hu claims the virtue that remains. Service of a teacher is greater than study.

A conquering answer

Meshuvah nitzachat: a permanent waywardness, read as a conquering answer.

Yerushalayim is called permanently wayward because the people thought they had a final argument. Three such answers appear.

The prophets also died, they said, so the destruction does not prove we were worse. The prophets died in their time, before the bad days. Your fathers died untimely at the destruction of the House. Prophecy continued while the people welcomed open criticism. When they became incensed at it, Hashem removed it. It was like Europe just before the war: the Chafetz Chaim and the other great leaders had already departed, and their presence itself had been a protection.

We were sold, and we were divorced, so the bond is broken. No bill of divorce was given, and nobody paid a price. They were sent away for their sins. Do teshuvah and the state ends. Nebuchadnezzar is called My servant for this reason. The title is that high: Moshe My servant, Yehoshua My servant. A slave's property still belongs to the master. There is no independent master. They had been in the land four hundred and forty years until Shlomo built the House, and four hundred and ten after. Eight hundred and fifty years. Ezekiel says the thought of becoming like the nations will not stand. Whether they want it or not, Hashem will force them back. In the days of Ahasuerus, when they began to mingle at the banquet, He sent Haman. Rav Nachman said this anger is for redemption.

The inclination of idolatry is too strong. It was given so there would be reward for controlling it. When the people grew weaker, the Men of the Great Assembly prayed three days and it was removed. The other tests are not that great. Hashem gives each person the ability to overcome them.

The three dodges fail. The righteous also died, persecution does not break the bond, and what remains can be overcome.

Without the people

Bela'am: belo am, without the people. Or bilum: he swallowed part of the people.

Four private persons lost the share: Bilam, Doeg, Achitofel, and Gehazi. Bilam wanted to die the death of the upright and to have his end with them. He spoke only in the name of Hashem, and even a house full of gold and silver would not move him against that word. Embers of Avraham's house still burned in Aram, and he caught them. Then he turned against the people. Twenty-four thousand died from his counsel. The Mechilta says the same of Pharaoh: he rose against the people, and the verse calls it rising against Hashem.

Ben Beor: he came upon an animal, a practice of Gentile sorcerers, done to draw a spirit of impurity. He was loyal to Hashem and not pure in every respect. Beor is also the line, not one man: Laban, who wanted to uproot Yaakov, and Cushan-Rishathaim, the same hatred in the days of the Judges. The Sifri answers how such a man can be a prophet. Prophets arose among the nations so they could not say that, had they been given prophets, they too would have been good. They were given the gift, and they misused it.

An enemy of Hashem's people is called an enemy of Hashem.

All the nations that forget

Yashuvu resha'im li-she'olah: the wicked return to Sheol, all the nations that forget God.

Why single out Bilam, unless other Gentiles can come? Rabbi Eliezer says the wicked of Israel, and all the nations that forget God, go to Sheol. Idolaters do not come. Rabbi Yehoshua says the verse says "that forget God," so only those who forget. Gentiles who do not worship idols come. Bilam believed. Had he not become an enemy of Israel, he would have been among them. The tape states that disagreement. It does not draw the line between forgetting God and ordinary Gentile life.

Only those who forget God are set aside. Believing was not enough once he turned against Israel.

Let my end be like his

Tamot nafshi mot yesharim: let my soul die the death of the upright, and let my end be like his.

If he died a natural death, his end would be with Israel. If he died by the sword, he would go to his people. He was slain by the sword in the war of Midian.

His own words marked the outcome.

The weasel and the cat

Karkushta ve-shunna: the weasel and the cat make a feast from the fat of the man with bad luck.

Moav and Midian were always at war. They united against Israel like two dogs on one flock: they fight each other until a wolf comes, and then both turn on the wolf. The lecture gives the same pattern three times. Put trust in the oppressed, and when the time comes they unite with the anti-Semites. In Sura, Jews who had lived by protection money were later hired by the king of Parthia, fell into bad ways, and the Gentiles took revenge on all the Jews of the district. In Syria the Jews sided with the Syrians against the Greeks, and those two then massacred the Jews. In Germany before the war the liberal Jews sided with the Protestants against the Catholics, and that anger fed the hatred of the Jews.

Enemies unite against the common prey. Trust belongs only in Hashem.

A father does not hate his son

Lodge here overnight, and I will bring you word.

The officers of Moav stayed. The officers of Midian left. If Bilam himself agrees to curse, perhaps Hashem would yield. If he must ask, it is a waste of time. A father does not hate his son. Rav Nachman said arrogance even against heaven obtains a result. It does not mean it pays.

The sugya of Bilam continues. This tape stops here: at first Hashem said to Moshe, you should not go with them.


Support the dissemination of Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l's shiurim at Kol Avigdor. To dedicate a daf: Sponsor a daf.