Torah from Rabbanim w Yirat Shamaym

Both hands

אִם יִרְצֶה הַשֵּׁם

י״ב כִּסְלֵו תשפ״ז

The sugya is Sanhedrin 107b. On 102a: Half a very good Jew.

Neither post nor transcript has been reviewed by Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l nor the Toras Avigdor organization.

As if greased

Aseh imi os le-tovah: make with me a sign for good.

David asked for a sign so that his enemies would see Hashem helping him. The sin was forgiven. The sign would not be in his lifetime.

At the Chanukat Beis ha-Mikdash: the dedication of the Temple, the Aron would not enter the gates. The greatest craftsmen had measured it. From Heaven the opening was made exactly the size of the Aron.

Shlomo said twenty-four tefillos and Tehillim 24. He was not answered. When he said al tashev pnei meshichecha, zechor chasdei David avdecha: do not turn away the face of Your anointed, remember the kindnesses of David Your servant, the gates yielded at once. The Aron went through as if greased.

The whole nation was present. The faces of David's enemies blackened with shame. Everyone saw that Hashem had forgiven him. The sign was given through the chesed of David.

He went to Damascus

Abaye said Elisha went to Damascus to bring Gehazi back to teshuvah: return.

Gehazi lost his chelek: his portion. He answered: I received from you that one who is machti as ha-rabbim: one who causes the many to sin, is not given the opportunity to repent. From Heaven they withhold the ordinary help. The effort must be much greater. It is still possible.

With a lodestone he made Yeravam's calves appear suspended in the air.

He engraved one of the Names in the mouth of a calf so that it announced the first two dibrot: commandments.

He pushed talmidim away from Elisha, the way a registrar turns students back. After he left, the bnei ha-nevi'im: the sons of the prophets, said the place had suddenly become too small.

Both hands

Lo ilon tehei smol doicheh ve-yamin mekareves: the left hand pushes away and the right hand draws near.

The Gemara criticizes Elisha. He pushed Gehazi away with both hands. Rav Miller zt"l: you will not find a counterpart to this in the literature of the world. Even a great navi: prophet, is criticized.

Yehoshua ben Perachyah pushed a talmid away with both hands. Tradition identifies that talmid with Yeshu. They came to an inn. The Rebbe praised the inn. The talmid thought he meant the hostess. He answered: but her eyes are round. The Rebbe drove him away. The talmid became a machti as ha-rabbim.

The same rule is said for the yetzer of procreation, for a child, and for a wife. Keep them at arm's length with the left hand. Draw them near with the right. A man must know how to measure each relationship. Elisha was too strict with his talmid.

Eight sheratzim

Has the time come to take the reward of the eight sheratzim: creeping things?

Naaman the metzora of Aram was healed in the Jordan. Elisha refused every gift, a kiddush Hashem. Gehazi ran after him, took two talents of silver and garments, and hid them. Elisha said: Did not my mind go with you? Is this the time to take silver, garments, olive trees, vineyards, sheep, cattle, slaves?

They were learning Perek Shemoneh Sheratzim. Elisha saw the spirit of tzara'as: the affliction, hovering over Gehazi. Gehazi thought that labor on each sugya was owed payment in this world. Nothing in this world is large enough to pay for Torah. The tzara'as of Naaman stuck to Gehazi and to his children forever.

Until Elisha

Until Elisha there was no recovery from illness.

He had three illnesses. One because he called the bears on the youths, alei keirach. One because he pushed Gehazi away with both hands. One from which he died. That last illness is not counted as an onesh: a punishment.

Until Avraham there were no external signs of old age. People confused Avraham and Yitzchak. Avraham asked for ziknah: old age, so that one knows to ask advice from the old and energy from the young.

Until Yaakov there was no illness before death. Yaakov asked for it so that a man can do teshuvah and give last orders to his family.

Elisha asked for recovery so that sickness can make a man a baal teshuvah: one who returns, and still leave him a second chance.

How the three illnesses of Elisha are to be weighed, and how far the criticism of pushing with both hands reaches once the talmid has already become a machti as ha-rabbim, is left open.


Support the dissemination of Rav Avigdor Miller zt"l's shiurim at Kol Avigdor. To dedicate a daf: Sponsor a daf.